Born Angelique Marie Martin on November 26, 1822, in Exeter, England, Lilly Martin Spencer immigrated with her family to Marietta, Ohio, in 1830 at the age of eight. Her parents, Gilles Marie Martin and Angelique LePetit Martin, were French expatriates who brought with them the fervor of French intellectual traditions. Her father was a progressive educator and social reformer, known for championing women’s rights and abolitionism, a stance unusual in 19th-century America. This enlightened, egalitarian household would profoundly shape Spencer’s worldview and later inform her choice of artistic subjects.
The family settled into modest but intellectually vibrant surroundings. Gilles Martin opened a girls’ school in Ohio and encouraged his daughter’s budding artistic talent. With few material resources but a wealth of cultural ideals, Lilly was raised in an environment that revered education, free expression, and the empowerment of women.
In 1844, at the age of 22, Lilly married Benjamin Rush Spencer, a tailor by trade. The couple eventually had 13 children, though not all survived infancy, a common tragedy of the era. Despite the enormous pressures of motherhood and a household that was often barely making ends meet, Lilly continued to paint, driven by a passion that defied her domestic obligations.
Benjamin was highly supportive of her artistic career and even gave up his own trade to manage her studio and art sales. This unconventional dynamic reversed traditional gender roles and reflected their deep mutual respect. However, the arrangement placed heavy financial strain on the family, and Lilly was often the sole breadwinner.
Benjamin Rush Spencer pencil drawing by Lilly Martin Spencer (Smithsonian)
Lilly Martin Spencer was largely self-taught, a remarkable fact considering the quality and technical skill of her work. She did, however, receive brief instruction from local artists in Ohio, and later took lessons with John Insco Williams and James Henry Beard, who helped hone her figure drawing and brushwork.
Though she never studied overseas or attended a major academy, a privilege reserved for wealthier, male artists, Spencer’s innate skill and observational acuity allowed her to rise above her limitations. Her early works gained attention in Cincinnati and then New York, where her talent would soon blossom on the national stage.
By the 1840s and 1850s, Lilly Martin Spencer had emerged as one of the most popular painters in America. She specialized in genre scenes that depicted the domestic life of middle-class women—images that were simultaneously tender, humorous, and deeply human.
In 1848, she exhibited at the National Academy of Design in New York, and in 1850, she was represented at the American Art-Union, where her works were distributed through a national lottery system. These reproductions reached thousands of American homes, making her a household name.
Her best-known painting, “Shake Hands?” (1854), shows a cheerful housewife in an apron offering her hand to an unseen guest a playful and progressive depiction of female agency. It remains one of the most reproduced American paintings of the 19th century.
Public Domain Link Notable works include:
Style & Technique analysis
Spencer’s style is grounded in American Realism, but infused with a painterly warmth and gentle satire. She had a gift for detail, from lace collars and fruit bowls to soft fabrics and the glint of light on glassware, but also imbued her subjects with emotional complexity.
Her compositional structure often draws the eye to a moment of interaction: a glance, a touch, a gesture, or an implied narrative. Her use of color is vibrant, but grounded in the earthy palette of domestic interiors. There is both intimacy and theatricality in her paintings, stories told on a small stage, but with universal appeal.
Unlike many of her male contemporaries, Spencer painted not the grand narratives of war or politics, but the emotional terrain of everyday life, motherhood, humor, fatigue, playfulness, and resilience, and she did so with an almost journalistic eye.
Spencer’s success in the 1850s was not without hardship. The family’s financial situation was frequently precarious, and despite her popularity, the economics of art production were rarely in her favor. Engravings of her work sold in high volume, but she did not always receive a fair share of the profits.
As tastes shifted after the Civil War toward academic art and later, Impressionism, Spencer’s genre scenes began to fall out of fashion. She continued to work into the 1870s and 1880s, but commissions dwindled, and her financial pressures mounted.
Still, her artistic spirit remained unbroken. She never stopped painting, even when personal tragedy struck or when the world’s attention turned elsewhere. Her life was a testament to the quiet strength of working women, and her art reflects that same unwavering commitment.
While not formally affiliated with any movement or school, Spencer was admired by both artists and critics in her time. Her work was praised in the press and collected widely by the middle class. She shared a thematic kinship with fellow American genre painters, as her female experience was singular.
Her independence, both personal and professional, won her the respect of abolitionists, feminists, and art reformers. Though she never aligned with overt political movements, her work subtly echoed the values of women’s autonomy and the dignity of domestic labor.
Lilly Martin Spencer passed away in New York City on May 22, 1902, at the age of 79. Though her last years were marked by obscurity and modest means, her contributions to American art were slowly being rediscovered.
She is buried at Woodlawn Cemetery in Bronx, New York, a serene resting place for many of New York’s artists and intellectuals.
Lilly Martin Spencer’s exclusion from art history was not just about her gender. Her work’s emphasis on domesticity, humor, and middle-class life led scholars of the 20th century, who favored avant-garde abstraction and male-dominated heroism, to dismiss her as sentimental or trivial.
Additionally, the very popularity that once made her successful ironically worked against her legacy. Because her prints were so widely circulated, her original paintings were undervalued as “commercial” or “decorative.”
In the 1980s and 1990s, feminist art historians began to reclaim Spencer’s place in the American art narrative. Her work is now housed in major institutions such as:
Today, Spencer is celebrated not just as a skilled painter but as a cultural storyteller who captured the emotional texture of American life with unmatched insight.
Her paintings now appear in major exhibitions on women artists, realism, and Victorian art. She is considered one of the first truly professional women painters in America who also depicted American women’s lives on their terms.
Lilly Martin Spencer’s life was filled with poignant contradictions:
These paradoxes make her story all the more human and her work all the more resonant with today’s viewers seeking authenticity, resilience, and forgotten truths.
At N1 Gallery, we believe in excavating brilliance from the margins of history. Lilly Martin Spencer reminds us that artistic greatness often blooms in kitchens, nurseries, and ordinary living rooms. She was not only a mother of many children but a mother of visual narratives that dignify the unseen labor of women.
Her art is not just about the 19th century; it’s about seeing joy, weariness, and power in places the world ignores.
Subscribe to our series on forgotten women artists
Explore the Work
I invite you to explore my paintings, layered, searching, and shaped by the same questions I ask of the artists I study. Visit My Gallery Art.
